Thank you, the property is a place that we are proud of and train our staff to help us keep it clean and orderly for your enjoyment.

Thank you for staying with us in our Small, Historic Hotel. We will be here when you return to Yellowstone and hope that you choose to stay with us again.

As a result of the lack of information the other booking sites choose to share about the details of our unique rooms, we have renamed the rooms to hopefully remove these, slight, misunderstandings. We are glad you gave it a chance in our 107 year old Hotel, it is simple and nice. We have 8 rooms that utilize a common restroom arrangement and Showers. The rest of our rooms have restrooms in the private suite, yours had the Original old soaking tub "1930's". Please come back soon.

Thank you so much for choosing to vacation with us while visiting Yellowstone.

We are sorry that an item was left in the room, the previous guest called to see if the cleaners collected a memory card that they may have misplaced. Breakfast, we gave you two coupons to two restaurants with a $7 dollar value each, because we do not operate a restaurant. Its a crying shame that you did not take advantage of them.

We are proud of what we have to share with our guests. Siple clean and friendly.

Just to be clear, the building is not Haunted, it does carry the "Spirt of Yellowstone". We have changed the stay from a 100 years ago, inside plumbing and electricity and available appliances. But we are happy that your felt the historical experience that we try to preserve.

We are sorry that you didn't seem to enjoy some of the things with us this time for your stay.The costs are still very competitive as compared to others close by. We explained in our policy that daily mad service would not be provided, we still tried to meet your requests.The noisy air handling systems are not as quiet as the new ones that are available on the market, if we were to upgrade then the costs would need to go up even more. We simply can be the best at everything it may be that next time you may need to stay elsewhere so that your needs can be met.

Thanks for the 5 star rating, the staff really works hard to deserve this.

The Madison is a historic property, thus we do not have an elevator the single flight of stairs that people have navigated for 111 years. We also have Motel rooms for those that select the Motel rooms if they can not do a single flight of stairs. The creaky floors are a natural feature and part of the amenity of staying in an original building constructed of logs in 1910-1912.

We are very happy that you enjoyed your stay with us!!

Thanks for choosing to say with us at the Madison Hotel Motel we are happy to see that your stay was what met your needs.

Thanks for the rating, wished that we could have been better feel free to email us with any comments that we could improve on.

Wished we had scored 10/10 for the rating of your stay. Is there anything we need to address to ensure a great rating from our next guest who stays with us?

Our staff is well trained and we truly apricate that your see there efforts. We try to design and find things that our traveling guests would like to have as souvenirs and such. the town of West Yellowstone is fantastic, the Timberline is a great café that has fantastic Pies.

We wish we could’ve gotten a 10 out of 10 rating during your stay. Is there anything we need to address to better the next guess’ stay?

We are so happy that you enjoyed your stay with us. We hope to see you during your next visit to Yellowstone.

Our staff is very good at their jobs. We are clearly not a New Marriot, we are an original 111 year old property that does the best we can to keep the costs of your stay down as you visit Yellowstone. The room that you had was recently remodeled and we just can not increase the footprint of the room. The parking is what it is also, this place was originally served by stage coach, eve the personal car parking is adapted to meet the needs. If you happen to be traveling with an RV, you can simply park in the "city" parking directly connected by this ally, it is free and safe. We hope that the next time you stay at a Marriot we will be remembered as the small little old hotel, that met your needs and was worth the comparison. Glad to have you stay with us.

This guest never finished checking in at our hotel, we refunded all his funds when he requested that and stayed elsewhere.

Thanks for staying with us, please come back on your next visit to Yellowstone.

Thanks, for staying with us on your Yellowstone visit.

Thank you for staying with us, the Staff is very appreciative of these complements.

We are fortunate to be in the center of town on the road that goes directly into Yellowstone in two blocks.Thanks for staying with the Madison

Yellowstone is Fantastic, we are glad to see that you felt that the Madison is also a fantastic place. Our staff is fantastic and it shows in their work.

Se are sorry that you feel that way, it is a Historic Place and simply doesn't meet everyone's expectations.

We are sorry we only earned 6 out of 10 points on your rating. Wish we knew where or what we had done or not done to score a 6. Hoping you enjoyed your visit in Yellowstone during your time with us.

We are so please to hear that you enjoyed your visit with us!! Thank you and we hope to see you next time you come to Yellowstone National Park.

Yes, as per our policies, our housekeeping staff does not enter the room at all during your stay with us. We do, however, service your room by request if you need your trash taken out or towels refreshed. We do not change sheets daily nor make the beds due to personal belongings always being left on or too close to the beds in the past. We do not move or touch any guests belonging, thus our policy. We are very happy you enjoyed your stay otherwise. We hope to see you during your next adventure to Yellowstone!!

Thanks for spending time with us here at the Historic Madison, our staff does an excellent job.

The Hotel is unique and memorable. We do our best preserving the feel it's had for 111 years, along with some modern benefits like the hot drink services on 24 hrs a day, WIFI, areas to lounge as the rooms are historically small.

Thanks, we hoped we could have done better, feel free to email us to let us know where we fell short of a higher rating.

The pricing is good here especially when you get the check-in meal tickets, and compare us to any one else, you did that when you booked. Thanks for coming to Yellowstone and making the Madison hotel part of your visit.

Thank you for choosing the Madison, we work hard to keep our customers happy and feeling good and safe as they are our priority while they visit Yellowstone.

Thanks, Our staffing is wonderful.

We are happy that you made the Madison part of your visit to Yellowstone.

West Yellowstone is a Great Small town with everything you need to experience Yellowstone's grandeur. The Sunday S'mores are a treat that we enjoy putting on with the guests being the best part.

This is the Oldest Hotel in West Yellowstone, you happened to book a room that had a shower in it then you rebook a higher cost room featuring the soaking bath tub only. Its difficult to understand your complaint, you got the exact room you booked, we do not randomly assign a room, you chose the amenities and the room. The Hotel was constructed in 1910-1920's and thus the sizing is appropriate to the period. the photos and descriptions are clear and exact. The heat, and the tub. The hottest it has reached is 29c this year so far, the tub is served with hot and cold water, thus you can regulate the temperature to your hearts desire thus meeting your exacting needs hot or cold. We clearly can't meet your expectations with providing you what you requested exactly, Historic room, with a Soaking tub, you even chose to pay more for this feature in your room. Thanks for coming to see Yellowstone.

We are so happy you enjoyed your stay with us! We will have a look at that window, thank you for telling us. We hope you include us on your next visit to Yellowstone.

Thank you for making the Madison part of your visit to Yellowstone. We’re happy you enjoyed yourself here with us.

We are very happy that you enjoyed your stay. Access to all the wonderful attractions inside and outside of Yellowstone is best from west! We hope that you include us on your next visit to Yellowstone.

Thanks for choosing to stay with The Historic Madison.

Travis, This is not fully at all accurate and your assessment of my Wife is not accurate in the least. Your comments are unfounded and totally inappropriate! We hope you and your wife enjoy your many stays elsewhere because you clearly didn't like our place. If I spoke about you or your wife that way you would be greatly offended, but you dug your own disgracefully hole not even knowing for certain who you actually spoke to.

All of these features are mentioned in our descriptions of the Historic hotel, its to bad that people can not be respectful to others as far as the noise.We also state in our policies that we do not do daily services, and at the desk we remind you that if you need something to schedule it with the front desk. if you want you bed made everyday you will need to bring you mother next time she will enjoy Yellowstone too.

We cover this refresh policy in our policies that you read at least a few times and signed off, telling you that we do not enter your room for a refresh, we will exchange towels at the door when notified. If you really must have someone make your bed, please bring your mother next time to Yellowstone, she will appreciate it. Even though your room cost was only 266 and if you recall it was less cost than the others and that motivated you to book with us.

Thanks, we appreciate that you selected and enjoyed your stay here at the Madison.

The room 117 is actually a "large room" for our property with a King bed, it is not as large as a modern Motel. West Yellowstone is a perfect launching spot for a visit to Yellowstone.

Thank you!

Thanks, the staff is incredible this year along with our guests. Thanks for coming to Yellowstone and staying at our Hotel.