Simply put, this is one of the nicest homes and location experiences we've had on a family vacation in a long time, perhaps ever. We visited Elbow Cay in July with family and friends, four adults and four teenagers. It was easy to assign rooms walking in, as every one of them was spacious and private, with their own bathrooms. The kitchen was open, the furniture comfortable, and the dining table perfect for both taking in the view and playing cards after dinner with the group. We spent most of our time on the unbelievable deck in the back. The house sits right on the beach, and every morning you could wake up to watch the sunrise on a large expanse of the back deck - there was always a breeze, so it felt as cool as it could and there were limited bugs as well. We closed down the day with cocktails looking out over the ocean (wire railing, so you can absolutely see the lovely view). There were many features about the place that made it a very relaxing spot: spacious and clean refrigerator, excellent AC, the beds and pillows were incredibly comfortable, you were able to make the bedrooms dark for sleeping if you wanted or keep the curtains open to the view instead, and there was a pool table in the basement that the kids and adults enjoyed.
In addition to the amenities, the location of the home was fantastic - a short walk to town to little gift shops and several restaurants/bars where we sometimes ate as a family, sometimes escaped as adults, and loved playing both trivia and bingo on a few nights. The location for this was perfect - the house was quiet, but not remote, and grocery stories, pharmacy, liquor stores were easy to access. We were also able to use the house's private dock where we docked our rental boat at night. This was a short golf cart ride away. Having a dedicated dock space limited any stress associated with renting and finding a public spot. At the end of the day when we were tired from a long day in the sun on the boat, this was such a luxury.
The caretaker of the the place, Robbie, was both attentive and fantastic. He was very thoughtful in his handling of our logistics, luggage, and helping us with any local information needed. He was incredibly responsive if we had an issue (we couldn't figure out the door lock one day, he was on it asap), and overall Robbie is a really nice guy that clearly cares about both the property itself and making sure we had a great time.
I would go back next week if I could.