They did a fabulous job renovating and remodeling this place. The layout, decor, and access to the loft are a huge upgrade from what it was before. The hot tub and patio are also a beautiful plus. The walkability to trails/hikes such as Baldy can not be beaten.
With that being said this is NOT a good place to stay if you have any issues with accessibility. They do mention that the "second floor" is accessible by spiral stairs but leave out that this is the whole house besides the bedrooms plus a very steep additional loft. This needs to be explained a little bit better in the description. We were lucky enough that this did not affect us too much but I could see this being a deal-breaker for many.
Unfortunately, another reason for the missing star was based on cleanliness. The counters were dirty, I had to scrub caked-on egg/cheese from them and we had full trash in the Master bedroom that had drinks and tissues from the previous tenants. Also, make sure to ask for the WIFI password well in advance. We could not find it anywhere in the house and had to work while we were there. Did not get a response until late that afternoon and missed a lot of needed work time.
All in all, it is a great place to stay with some little hiccups that management needs to address and make sure are taken care of in the future; could be a 5-star listing.