This is a mid-size villa that will grow on you. We were two couples traveling together and the house was sized right for the four of us. It gave us each our own private bath - one as an ensuite and the other across the hall.
Here's what we liked...
Kitchen - it was loaded with everything you could possibly need in preparing meals, with one exception - no microwave. But, it had ample dishes, pots and pans. Nice table in the middle of the room for conversation.
Loggia - the outdoor patio was where we spent our time. Quaint, comfortable with decent views of Lucca in the distant. We stoked up the outdoor pizza oven and enjoyed some homemade pizza.
Swimming pool - Nice setting with 10 various chairs and lounges. It has a separate bathhouse to use to avoid having to hoof it down to the house. It's around 20 steps up to the pool, but it's clean, comfortable and very private.
Bedrooms - Air conditioned and spacious. Beds were firm but comfortable. Lots of storage via built-in cabinets and wardrobes. One bedroom has an ensuite bath and the other three bedrooms share one full bath. Perfect for two couples traveling together, but more than that could be less than ideal.
Location - The villa is only a couple of miles from stores and restaurants. Very private and quiet. The last mile or two up to the villa is very narrow and winding so be prepared. We discovered several delightful restaurants within 15 minutes.
This is a hidden gem and a great value! Recommended.
Since you asked, here are some issues that could improve the overall experience:
Lighting - Could be improved. Many of the fixtures are old and could benefit from a facelift. There's a difference between being "old and quaint" and simply "old".
Landscaping - the property could benefit from some serious trimming and pruning to open up the vistas of Lucca below. It feels a bit overgrown in key areas. It would emphasis one of the property's greatest assets.
Trash containers - While I admire the recycling program, it is tough to manage when there is no way to separate the trash indoors. I suggest additional indoor containers to make it easier.
Microwave - Counterspace is tight, but consider some way to add a small microwave even if it's just to heat up a cup of coffee.
New cushions - consider new outdoor cushions for the loggia and for pool area to improve comfort of seating.
All are minor issues and didn't distract from a great week at the property