The Good: The location, the property itself, furniture was great, outdoor space great, host very responsive and nice.
The Bad: Rats and Cockroaches. We've been coming to St. John for 15+ years and have never had this before. Rats in the house. Droppings on the couch, droppings/urine on the kitchen counters, droppings on the bathroom countertop. Host was great to come and put out more traps, but there were still more. Running behind the TV shelves when we were watching a movie. Running in the kitchen when I was loading dishwasher. Islands always have critters, but the cockroaches were excessive. Coming out of the couch when you'd sit down. Climbing around the kitchen cabinets and in the pantry. I'd kill 3-4 an evening around the kitchen. We have never stayed anywhere on the island that had rats, or this many cockroaches. We have had an iguana problem in one place, but nothing like this.
One more note in case it matters to someone's needs, the internet is well-below average, even for the island. It's generally much better around Cruz Bay than Coral, but even for Coral this was bad. Yes there are streaming services on the TV, but the movies we streamed suffered from excessive buffering most of the time. My speedcheck app measured it at .8 mbps. Not really useful for anything. In sum, this is a property that has great views, good location, and really good furnishings and layout. But for the amount of $ charged, the rats and cockroaches put a significant damper on the enjoyment of the trip.