Coming from current rental home owners elsewhere:
Good-
House was clean, fairly well stocked. Clear instructions were emailed. There were plenty of towels and linens. The kitchen was well stacked and also had room for food brought in. Water pressure was great, showers work clean and nice. Loved that the bathrooms had shelves and empty baskets for guests use. There were plenty of beach towels. There was laundry soap and dishwasher soap so we didn't have to purchase any. There was a hair dryer & coffee maker w/ filters. Pool was clean. Lots of places to sit outside. Two bikes in the garage to use as well as a a full size cooler, A wagon & beach chairs.
Could improve-
Communication felt a little bit like a third grade teacher scolding us about what we could and couldn't do on vacation before we got there... Repeatedly sending emails & texts regarding the quiet time on the island and when trash & recycle days were, where NOT to park, and other Rules, And then it was posted in the kitchen, and in the packet we picked up from Horizon.
The house could use a little to TLC, noticed a gap between the master bathroom and the master bedroom wear water from the shower would spill into. Dishwasher needs a couple screws at the top because when you pull out the drawers it tips out. There are a lot of pans that are scratched and rusty. Feels like you could leave an extra pack of TP and a roll of paper towels when guests rent for a week.